Rate Trends in Commercial Insurance: Property Stabilizes, Casualty Splits, Auto Struggles

As 2026 begins, commercial insurance buyers are encountering a marketplace that looks very different from the relentless rate hikes of recent years. The story now is one of stabilization in property insurance, divergence in casualty lines, and continued challenges in commercial auto. Together, these trends highlight how the insurance landscape is evolving — offering relief in some areas, complexity in others, and persistent difficulties in one of the most important lines for businesses with vehicles.

Property Insurance: Signs of Stability

Commercial property insurance has been one of the most volatile segments in recent memory. Catastrophic losses from hurricanes, wildfires, and severe storms, combined with inflationary pressures and reinsurance constraints, drove steep increases across the country. For many businesses, renewals over the past three years felt like an uphill battle, with higher premiums, tighter terms, and reduced capacity.

Now, industry reports show that the tide is turning. Rate increases are moderating, capacity is expanding, and underwriting appetite is returning in many regions. Improved reinsurance conditions are playing a major role, as global reinsurers have added capacity and softened their stance after several years of tightening. This has filtered down to insurers, who are more willing to write property risks and compete for accounts.

That said, stabilization does not mean uniform relief. Properties in catastrophe‑exposed areas — such as wildfire‑prone California or hurricane‑vulnerable Florida and the Gulf Coast — still face selective underwriting, higher deductibles, and stricter terms. But for many businesses outside those zones, 2026 marks the first time in years that property renewals feel less pressured.

Casualty Insurance: Diverging Paths

Casualty insurance is presenting a more complex picture. Accounts with clean loss histories and lower‑hazard exposures are seeing softening rates, sometimes even modest decreases. This is particularly true for industries with strong safety records and limited exposure to litigation.

At the same time, higher‑risk industries — such as construction, transportation, and energy — continue to face tough renewals. Businesses operating in litigious jurisdictions are also feeling the impact of social inflation, nuclear verdicts, and litigation funding, all of which are contributing to upward pressure on liability costs. Carriers are responding with higher premiums, stricter terms, and closer scrutiny of risk management practices.

The result is a casualty market where outcomes vary widely depending on risk profile and jurisdiction. For some buyers, 2026 may bring welcome relief; for others, the challenges remain significant.

Commercial Auto: Persistent Struggles

Commercial auto remains one of the most difficult lines in the marketplace. Despite more than a decade of rate increases, underwriting losses persist. Rising repair costs, medical inflation, and adverse loss development continue to weigh heavily on results.

Fleet operators and transportation businesses nationwide should expect continued premium pressure. Carriers remain reluctant to ease terms until loss ratios improve, and many are tightening underwriting standards further. Innovation in telematics, driver monitoring, and fleet management technology offers some hope, but structural challenges in commercial auto — including accident frequency and severity — are unlikely to resolve quickly.

The Big Picture

For commercial insurance buyers, the rate environment in early 2026 is no longer defined by across‑the‑board increases. Property insurance is stabilizing, casualty insurance is splitting into favorable and unfavorable paths depending on risk, and commercial auto remains stubbornly unprofitable.

Together, these trends paint a nuanced picture of the marketplace: relief in some areas, continued challenges in others, and a reminder that the commercial insurance landscape is constantly evolving. Businesses across the U.S. will see these dynamics reflected in their renewals, making 2026 a year of both opportunity and caution.

[return to top]

In this issue:

This Just In ... Cyber Insurance Market Shifts Power to Buyers

Rate Trends in Commercial Insurance: Property Stabilizes, Casualty Splits, Auto Struggles

Regional Catastrophes,National Lessons

Regulatory Priorities for 2025: Resilience, Solvency, and Innovation

Liability Limits and Large Loss Trends

The information presented and conclusions within are based upon our best judgment and analysis. It is not guaranteed information and does not necessarily reflect all available data. Web addresses are current at time of publication but subject to change. SmartsPro Marketing and The Insurance 411 do not engage in the solicitation, sale or management of securities or investments, nor does it make any recommendations on securities or investments. This material may not be quoted or reproduced in any form without publisher’s permission. All rights reserved. ©2025 The Smarts Publishing. Tel. 877-762-7877. www.smartspublishing.com